Metaphor Studies

by Lia Purpura

Study with Skinned Muskrat

The story on the radio is being reported in a very particular key. New York bemused. If you’ve grown up with this, it just sounds like fact: how quirky and unfathomable are the provinces! For just an instant though, really quick, the way a gray sky before rain will select a few clouds for brightening, the tone shifts and feels more expansive, patient—like muskrat-skinning could be something else, too, could stand for ambition and translate into values we all understand: set a challenge, work hard, move up in the ranks. Listening for this note checks smirkyness, quiets a certain form of laughter at the down-home thangs people do. And if that’s the way the listening goes, even briefly, if things get metaphorical, then we get to be Rhonda, who won this year’s contest. She’s us at our best. A version of diligence. Someone who thinks at night to herself how she might make improvements, at a blank, stoplight moment considers adjustments of tools and materials, the best ordering of gestures. Runs replays. Feels, even as she cuts an apple, the musculature’s joy in its training, and elsewhere, at other times of day—say, undressing a very muddy child—how adept the body has grown at improvising around slippery problems. You can hear all this. You just have to be alert. Catch the moment when the reporter slows. Deepens her question. Depatronizes. Gives Rhonda a chance to speak for herself. Gets, actually, interested.

Hearing that feels like turning a corner and catching breeze on an otherwise very hot, busy, street.

❧

Study with Landfill and Bodies

A gash hurts, hurts, bleeds, scabs over, and in time mends, as grass comes to a place once torn and bare, grows over a landfill so you can say of it hill, or far rise. Maybe sanctuary.

Lay the words on a scale: on one side the body, on the other, the land. Let city dump mean your cut arm. Let greened be your skin made whole.

What once was ruined land might be reclaimed.

To have a doctor who’d say it like this! Your body will be a field again.

As will Fresh Kills in Staten Island, N.Y. (“kills” from the Dutch for stream, brook, or channel), a stretch of land three times the size of Central Park. At its peak, as a dump, Fresh Kills received 29,000 tons of garbage a day, from all five boroughs. The stench was so bad that, passing it, en route to the city, you had to breathe into a handkerchief. Gulls roved in clouds that darkened the sky. Rats were a kingdom. The highest mound was eye to eye with the Statue of Liberty.

In 2001, two million tons of wreckage from 9/11 was trucked to Fresh Kills for sorting.

(No, the name wasn’t lost on anyone).

For months a dump was an open grave. More than 300 people were identified from the 4,257 remains.

And though it’s been closed for over ten years, passing marsh grasses and miles of soft green still surprises—the way, long after recovery, getting up from a chair and running to answer a knock at the door, no wincing,  no forethought—still feels miraculous.

A rain plus time can equal a park. In thirty more years, according to plan, Fresh Kills will include a seed farm, nursery, bird sanctuary; a field full of wind turbines, bike trails, a lush, green memorial where people can walk, picnic, remember.

A dump restored is a body healed.

A scar is a plaque on the body’s field.

If you can make the words work, get the pictures right (body of land, leg of a journey—see, all along you’ve been training) such a leap will sanctify, make a place more, and you more fully yourself.

❧

Three Brief Studies of Spring

Almost ten years ago this spring, I was desperate about many things, but my grandmother was still alive. It was hard to see the froth of a dogwood, to pass a magnolia’s tender pink cream or the fresh tips of evergreens touched by wind. Everything hurt. Now I breathe freely. walk and tread currents of rough scent rising—mud, spice, cut grass, leaf mold, some wild bloom swelling, releasing a milky sweatiness. I’m washed in waves of sidewalk heat. Shade in bowers, tides of noise—all here, and I’m alongside. And my grandmother is gone.

What is that?

A Möbius strip.

.

On my way home after a very long day, I have to decide: should I walk in the street, or climb the hill and walk along the reservoir at the top. Street: I get to see used condoms, coffee cups, broken sparkles of windshield glass, tiny glassine baggies for crack—basic, shining urban grit I use to put together the story of that spot. Going up the hill: I get an expanse of clear water and scent of air sweetened by the breath of plants at the banks. Today, up sounds best, like what I need most. Spirit is located up above, no? That I might rise above my worries that way? By walking upward, lift my heart? (Though the reservoir is fenced. A security camera was just installed. And a maintenance crew mowing is loudly…)

Metaphors get compromised. Get eroded and need updating. Rerouting. Reinventing. Reconstituting.

.

From a stump, green shoots grow. How tiring to see that and think, “Ah, spring!” Or, one tulip comes out before all the others in the largest bed in the park. So what is that—bravery? (And skipping ahead, late August: goldfinch-on-a-spent-sunflower as harbinger-of-fall? Black-eyed Susans, split and bent, though tall, up to my chin = holding on?. ) Drops of fresh blood on the sidewalk (how fatly they pool before drying out; days later they’ve made a trail of brown stains)—what would that be: the life force ebbing?

Stop, known equivalencies! I want things discovered, just come upon, new—for spring flowers, bare and unassigned, to fly past “rebirth.” Let green be otherwise than spring. Let shoots finger the throat of air. Let stumps not sprout, but harbor and castle, be brainpans for a hive of thought, stirred awake and hungry and taking off for a sweeter elsewhere.

New needles on the pine out back: broom of the air.

Shining cat on the neighbor’s roof: a black nest of sun.

That sort of thing.

❧

Subway Study

Seeing a guy on the subway one morning (notable for his purple-and-yellow-striped slicker and red-fringed umbrella), and then later that day, different line, the crosstown, there he is again: that means, if I make it mean. Suggests the workings of fate uncharted, all the meetings that go unnoticed. Falling cartoon anvils that missed me. Chances gratitude, overlooked. Occasions for fear I didn’t have to take in.

There he goes, up the stairs and away.

To be for someone a metaphor is to be not yourself but another’s measure, the site where chance firms and vastness brightens—you, trying to get home after a long day at work, in your stifling raincoat and couture umbrella, your throat sore, your head hurting, who are tired and just want to lie down.

❧

Study With Automaton

Seated at a desk, this one was built to sketch a ship. He’s geared to hold a long brass pen engraved with twining fleur de lis. The boy with pink porcelain cheeks and a swipe of brown hair pauses and tilts his face up as if conjuring the next perfect mast-and-rigging, before turning back to his paper to draw it. He adds curled waves and tiny sailors. I can hear the soft cams at work on a flag, a sail, an expanse of deck; the shush and whir of a thought turning over, a quiet click in the neck as he nods, his left hand caressing a thought-shape in air, so that what I feel is—and here, I can’t peel back the skin of it very easily. It—the sensation—pushes past vanity (how Romantic one looks posing), past the uncanny (shiver of the inanimate made flesh)—and into a certainty: I know what he’s feeling.

I’m not arguing that an automaton feels. Just that what goes on lands squarely in me. And that the ache in my shoulder, from sitting at my own desk all day, is expressed so precisely by the hitch in his bright silver shoulder.

❧

Optical Illusion Study

I’ve always liked that image wherein a young woman with a fur stole, looking over her shoulder, shifts (if you refocus from black space to white) to an old woman with a pointy, hooked nose. I enjoy that little shudder, the sense that each contains the other—how a single line slips from delicate necklace to tight-lipped grimace! But then, when I saw it the other day, this came, a refinement: to really know what the picture’s suggesting, I’d have to look in a mirror and be shocked. I’d have to feel age as a scrim, or a veil over my real face—and I don’t feel that yet. I still look like what I know myself to be. I understand the illusion, but not intimately.

Some metaphors one has to grow into.

❧

Study with Frisbee

We get the red disk stuck in a tree—it’s a blustery day but the thing’s held fast by a branch (as an apple would be) and I think if we wait the wind will blow it out (which would make the Frisbee a windfall fruit), but when a gust picks up, the disk instead lifts up like s sigh and adjusts. Then a very big gust comes and the Frisbee falls. And there it is: a way to understand being subject to forces one can’t resist. I watch and feel what buffeted is: my heart pushed around, in wind, on a bright fall day.

❧

Studies with Children in the Background

In the morning sky, the moon’s a white water stain. Then it’s a lozenge dissolved by noon. Later, as evening comes, we say it rises, it has a face. It looks upon us.

A fresh cut stump in the woods is a moon.

Shone upon, upturned faces are lakes at night.

A face has its dark side. Joy waxes and wanes.

Tides of excitement can overcome a child at a birthday party.

Say a father’s away at war; he might as well be in another galaxy, in his tank, on Skype as the cake is cut. A child could say, My father is a star. My father is sand. And she’d be right in so many ways.

.

Sometimes when we saw the war on TV—and the villages burned, and the people, the children, scattered and ran—the picture would dissolve. We said it turned to snow, it was winter after all. It was very hot in Vietnam but all the kids still turned to snow, they were that away and that close.

.

Once I hovered a finger over a pill bug, touched it gently and watched it roll up—and then curled up next to it. Are you hurt, my mother said. No, I’m a pill bug. By which I meant, I don’t want to be seen. I’m gray. I can disappear into the cobbles along the driveway. I’m a pebble. A pin feather. Ice. Sand. Snow. Safe.

❧

Study With Plate Glass Window

A pebble. A pin feather. A broken-necked sparrow on sparrow-brown stones, speckled, stilled, and partly hidden. The moss green, the chinks dark, the peace in between. River stones as smooth as eggs. A grief exactly that round and contained. A finger in moss for the velvety damp. Ruffle of feathers the weight of an eyelash. A hard-bent wrist the very angle of broken. Try, with your body: I’m that, or, that’s me (the order hardly matters) one thing is another—neither’s only itself, but spreads across continents, yards, galaxies, species.

To alter one thing, then, is to alter another.

❧

Loon Study

To alter one thing is to alter another.

If a metaphor is an ecosystem, a balancing of unseen dependencies, “You’re a loon” as a way to say “crazy” isn’t so simple anymore. Loons who eat fish poisoned by mercury and breathe air contaminated by coal-fired plants can’t incubate properly. Their eggs suffer from exposure, don’t hatch, or get raided. Mercury wrecks the nervous system. The loons don’t act right; they’re not loon-like but nervous, uncoordinated, cheerless, exhausted. Their feathers grow in unevenly, so flying is harder, migration’s thrown off and they can’t maintain breeding territory.

And there’s this: “mad as a hatter,” in centuries past, referred to the dementia caused by mercury used in the manufacturing of felt hats. (“To hatter” also means to weary, to wear out with fatigue). Milliners suffered loon-like symptoms, all the confusions and disturbances, tremors, sweating, loss of hair, teeth, and nails—you have dig only a little to learn this.

If you want to reflect the moment’s concerns, language can’t mean in ways it used to. “You’re a loon” might still indicate “crazy,” as expressed by the bird’s ghosted, shuddery call, but meanings change and layer up. Poison shifts even etymological DNA. If a loon is driven mad by toxic waste, if it cannot mate, and it cannot care—for its young its fate—you’ll have to recognize that in its call. And if that stirs you, imagine the sound you’d make, late summer night, at a cool, blue lake in the Adirondacks, you there with your mate, with no way of increasing yourself—yourselves—as a pair. And how desperate you’d sound, in your grief.

❧

Cleveland Study

Try saying The earth is my brother. Try not feeling dopey, or worrying that you’ll be seen as a faux-Native, hippie freak. Try thinking “my brother someone I love/rely on. Who angers me. Whom I don’t entirely understand. Whom I’m tied to by fate. Who’s complicated.”

Try: My brother is a bird of prey. A bracing, cold river; overriding its banks.

Then what?

Go further.

Try River-seen-from-a-plane as Blood-moving-in-veins.

A-river-bent-in-S’s as Snake. If ferociously bright—way brighter than a black racer in sun—say A snake in flames, A burning snake, which is not fanciful but real as a twisted river burning. The Cuyahoga (in Iroquois, “crooked river”), 1969, sludge-filled, oily, and poisonous. Nothing lived in that open sewer. Not a sunfish. Not a black snake. And finally, that fire, the thirteenth recorded since the 1850s, was enough. You can trace the origins of the Environmental Protection Agency to this time, and in part, to this place. The Cuyahoga’s not yet recovered, but so far, sixty species of fish have been counted and in healthy sections; beavers, herons, and eagles have been spotted nesting along the banks of the river.

Kids fishing or paddling along today don’t know the moon once effloresced, and sun rainbowed up in oily swells. That the air was sulphur. That once, we made of a gift a sewer.

It’s hard to see Bright skin of water prickling in wind as Cicatrice.

❧

Study with Mythological Figures in the Background

Once I stayed at a house where the owners kept a stone bird in a cage. The bird’s absolute stillness, the impossibility of song felt cautionary. Wherever I sat, I couldn’t get away from it, I mean the very real, very old truth—that people get turned from themselves into many things—salt, nightingales, gold, the loveliest of lakeside flowers. And their names become a way to think about seasons, the sky, failings, luck, circumstance.

Look anywhere, at anything, and you’ll find yourself there; the world offers us to ourselves at every turn: Midas touch. Narcissist. Metaphors are terribly generous that way.

Published on November 17, 2026

First published in Harvard Review 45.